New Year’s Eve and Oysters

As a kid growing up on the American prairie in the mid-20th Century, seafood was a rare and exotic commodity. It’s a long way to either coast from South Dakota. We were occasionally treated to shrimp—tiny pink things from a bag in the freezer, complete with freezer burn. Yum! Not. I don’t recall ever seeing clams or salmon or halibut on my dinner plate. I was, however, somewhat familiar with oysters, of all things. Oyster stew was served for dinner on New Year’s Eve. It was a tradition that was never explained, and I never asked about it.

Oyster Stew

Oyster stew wasn’t my favorite meal. The oysters were grey and slimy looking; they were about the size of a half dollar and looked like something hacked up in a coughing fit. They had a weird briny smell, and they always came out of a large can.

I never tasted these oysters other than as slightly rubbery globules in a steaming butter-and-milk stew floating among bits of onion and celery and little round crackers. My brother and I both thought the oyster crackers were the best part of the meal.

Oysters in the Midwest
Oysters being shucked

My brother says oyster stew was a New Year’s tradition in our mother’s family. She grew up with oyster stew in rural South Dakota and continued the tradition because Dad liked it. Oysters have a long culinary history in America. They were already a dietary mainstay among East Coast Natives when the Pilgrims arrived. Abundant and easy to harvest, oysters were prized for their nutrition and flavor. As American settlers moved West, so did their taste for oysters. Barrels of oysters in seawater were packed in ice and straw and shipped by rail on tracks newly lain across the prairies. That explains how my ancestors stuck in the middle of North America had access to coastal shellfish.

Besides nutrition and flavor, oysters have long had a reputation for promoting fertility and libido, two important factors in a developing nation with a growing population. Coincidentally, New Year’s has been celebrated with fertility rites since at least the Roman Empire. So, oyster stews helped “stir things up” in little houses on the prairie on cold winter nights.

The Tradition Continues
Oysters Melanie!

Anyway, holiday traditions can be tenacious. I’ve never made an oyster stew, but 25 years ago I came across a baked oyster dish in a recipe book from the legendary Seattle seafood restaurant, McCormick and Schmick’s. It wasn’t a stew, but the recipe included sautéed oysters returned to their shells and immersed in dilled butter cream with Champagne and topped with a dollop of French brie. It reminded me of my parents’ oyster tradition, so I started making it as an appetizer for the New Year’s celebrations we either hosted or attended in our neighborhood in suburban Minneapolis.

I hadn’t made Oysters Melanie for years but spending the Holiday Season on the Mendocino California coast inspired me to revisit it. I adjusted the recipe to work as the main dish along with a salad for New Year’s Eve. Warm crusty bread replaces the oyster crackers of my youth, but when I make this oyster dish, I’ll always remember New Year’s Eves with my parents and their oyster stew.


Baked Oysters Melanie

Course Appetizers
Keyword Cooking, Recipe
Prep Time 20 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Total Time 40 minutes
Servings 12 people
Author Daniel


  • 1/2 cup Champagne or other dry sparkling wine
  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • 1 tablespoon flour
  • 2 tablespoons butter room temperature, barely firm
  • 24 live oysters shucked with nectar; retain bottom shells
  • 12 ounces brie 24 slices (1/8 inch each) to top oysters
  • 2 tablespoons fresh dill chopped
  • pinch sea salt
  • dash fresh ground pepper
  • 4 cups rock salt
  • Lemon wedges and dill sprigs for garnish


  • Preheat oven to 400 degrees.
  • Spread the rock salt on a baking sheet and arrange the oyster shells on the salt. The salt helps distribute the heat and stabilizes the oysters.
  • Combine champagne and cream in a saucepan. Reduce over medium heat to about 1 cup, about 10 minutes. Blend the flour into the butter and add mixture a little at a time to the champagne cream while stirring constantly until the mixture thickens. Season with sea salt, pepper and the chopped dill or tarragon.
  • Remove the sauce from the heat and reserve.
  • Heat oysters and their nectar in a saute pan 3-5 minutes until the edges of the oysters begin to curl.
  • Put an oyster in each shell, spoon 2 teaspoons of sauce over each and top with a slice of brie.
  • Bake oysters 3 to 5 minutes or until the sauce is bubbly and the cheese is melted and browned.
  • Arrange oysters on the serving plates and garnish with lemon and fresh dill sprigs. Serve with warm crusty bread and remaining Champagne.


Source: McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood Restaurant Cookbook
Substitute: You can substitute 1 Tablespoon chopped fresh tarragon for the dill for stronger anise flavor.
Preparation time: 20 minutes (depending on how fast you can shuck oysters).

Like what you read? Leave us a comment! Your name and/or email will never be used for commercial purposes.